8 min read

The Right A/B Testing Strategy for Email Success

Elevate your email game! Discover how A/B Testing can turn your emails from meh to marvelous. Step inside our guide!
Written by
Vikas Jha
Published on
June 27, 2023

Introduction to Email A/B Testing

A/B testing is not a one-and-done deal; it's a continuous process that helps keep your email marketing strategy agile and effective.

Diving into the world of email marketing can be overwhelming, given the factors contributing to a successful campaign. Crafting the perfect message that strikes a chord with your audience is challenging. This is where A/B testing or split testing comes into play. This section will guide you through the world of email A/B and email split testing, a potent tool that can dramatically enhance the effectiveness of your email marketing campaigns.

Understanding A/B Testing: The Marketer's Perspective

The Basics of A/B Testing

A/B testing, also commonly referred to as split testing campaigns, is a technique used to determine the effectiveness of different versions of an email campaign. It involves creating two variations of the same email – Version A and Version B – with one varying element. This could be anything from the subject line to the email body or the call to action. These versions are then sent to two similar segments of your target audience to evaluate which garners a higher response regarding open or click-through rates.

Real-World Application of A/B Testing

For instance, if you're unsure whether your marketing email should include long-form or short-form copy, you can create two email versions accordingly. A/B testing allows you to both test version and determine which version resonates more with your audience, enabling data-driven decisions in your email marketing strategy.

The Importance of A/B Testing in Email Marketing

Why A/B Testing Matters

A/B testing plays a critical role in successful email marketing campaigns. By enabling a deeper understanding of customer behavior, it facilitates content tailored to meet audience preferences. What works for one email marketing campaign might not necessarily work for another, and A/B testing allows continuous testing and refinement of strategies, making it an integral part of effective email marketing.

The Power of A/B Testing

At first glance, A/B testing might seem like a minute step in the broader spectrum of your email marketing strategy. However, uncovering a winning version through testing can significantly increase your open rates, click-through rates, and, ultimately, conversions. Even minor changes, such as tweaking the subject line or altering the word order, can lead to statistically significant improvements, elevating your campaign's success and conversion rate.

The Statistical Relevance of A/B Testing

Deciphering the Numbers

Understanding the results of an A/B test is as crucial as creating effective versions. Here's where the concept of statistical significance comes into the picture. If your A/B test results are statistically significant, it means the differences in performance between your two email versions are not a result of chance.

Making Sense of Statistical Significance

Suppose version A of your email achieves an open rate of 20% while version B of emails achieves 25%. While it might be tempting to declare version B as the winner, statistical significance considers the sample size and the number of responses, ensuring this difference is not a result of random variations or small sample size.

If your target audience comprises 200 potential customers and 100 each received versions A and B, the results may not be statistically significant due to the small sample size. However, if the test involved 2000 recipients for each version, with similar open rate percentages, you could confidently conclude that version B performs better, thanks to the reliability provided by the larger sample size.

A/B testing is not a "nice-to-have" but a "must-have" for successful email marketing campaigns (3). By understanding its importance, knowing how to implement it, and being able to interpret its results, you can harness the power of A/B testing to create winning email campaigns that engage and convert your target audience. From subject lines to email body copy and call-to-actions, you can A/B test every element to ensure your email marketing resonates with your readers.

Your next step? Start planning your A/B test. Remember to test one variable at a time and use a sufficiently large sample size to ensure the statistical significance of your results. As you progress, you'll refine your approach, understand your audience better, and create more impactful email marketing campaigns.

The Core Elements of Email A/B Testing

Even a small change in your email, like the word order in the subject line, can have a significant impact on open rates.

Embarking on your email A/B testing journey requires a comprehensive understanding of its core elements. Every aspect matters, from identifying variables to evaluating to understanding the nuances of subject lines, content, personalization, visuals, style, copy, length, tone, and call-to-actions.

Identifying Variables for Testing

In A/B testing for email campaigns, the variables refer to the elements you can change or modify in your emails. When altered, these elements can significantly impact your email campaign's performance.

Identifying the right variables for your A/B test is the first step toward running an effective test. Variables could include the email subject line, email body copy, images used, call-to-action buttons, and your email layout. However, remember to test only one variable at a time to ensure that the changes in the email performance can be accurately attributed to that variable.

For example, if you're testing both the subject line and the email body or text link in the same test and you notice an increase in the click-through rate between two subject lines, it would be challenging to attribute the improvement to either variable.

The Impact of Subject Lines, Word Order, and Content

The subject line of an email is often the first interaction your audience has with your email. It can significantly impact the open rates of your email campaign. Testing different subject lines can provide insights into what resonates with your audience and what prompts them to open the email.

The word order in your subject line or email body can also considerably impact the success of your email campaign. Even small changes, like starting with a verb instead of a noun, or placing the most crucial information at the beginning, can significantly change your click-through or conversion rates with email clients.

The content of your email is another vital variable to test. It encompasses everything from the message you're sharing, the tone of the email, the language used, and the overall communication style. The content should be engaging and resonate with your target audience's preferences.

The Role of Personalization and Visuals

Personalization in email marketing refers to creating tailored experiences for your subscribers based on their interests, behaviors, and past interactions. By using personalized emails, for example, you can improve open rates, click-through rates, and conversion rates. A/B testing different personalization strategies, such as using the recipient's first name in the subject line or email body, can give you data on your audience's preference.

Visual elements in your email, including images, videos, infographics, and design elements, significantly attract your audience's attention. These elements can be tested to find the winning combination that increases engagement and conversions.

The Significance of Style, Copy, Length, Tone, and Call to Actions

The style of your email refers to how it looks and feels. This can include elements like color schemes, fonts, layout, and more. A/B testing can help you understand which style preferences your audience has.

The copy of your email refers to the words you use to convey your message. Testing different copy strategies can help you understand what language, tone, and voice resonate best with your audience.

The length of your email can significantly impact how well your message is received. While some audiences prefer short and crisp emails, others may appreciate a more detailed approach. A/B testing can reveal the ideal email length for your target audience.

The tone of your email can set the mood for your message. Depending on your brand's voice and audience's preferences, the tone can range from formal and professional to casual and friendly.

The call to action (CTA) is one of the most crucial elements in your email. It prompts your readers to take a desired action, such as visiting your website, purchasing, or signing up for a webinar. Testing different CTAs can reveal which ones are most effective at driving conversions.

In conclusion, the core elements of email A/B testing play a crucial role in optimizing your email campaigns. Understanding and testing these elements can significantly improve your email marketing performance.

Optimizing Through Exploration: What to A/B Test and What to Gain

In your journey of optimizing email campaigns through A/B testing, knowing what elements to test and understanding the potential benefits of testing opportunities are essential. Here, we provide a comprehensive list of things you can A/B test and the valuable insights you can gain from each.

  1. Subject Lines: The first point of contact between your email and the recipient. Testing subject lines can help increase open rates by revealing what kind of wording, length, and style your audience responds to best.
  2. Email Body Copy: This is where your main message lies. You can increase engagement and conversions by A/B testing different structures, tones, and content types.
  3. Personalization: Personalized emails often have higher engagement rates. Testing personalization elements, such as addressing recipients by their first name, can improve click-through and conversion rates.
  4. Call-to-Action (CTA): The CTA is your email's key driver of conversions. Testing different CTA texts, colors, placement, and styles can help increase your click-through and conversion rates.
  5. Email Design and Layout: The visual appeal of your email plays a significant role in user engagement. A/B testing different designs, color schemes, layouts, and visual elements can boost your email's effectiveness.
  6. Images and Videos: Visual email content can influence engagement and conversions. Testing different images, video content, and placement can provide insights into your audience's preferences.
  7. Send Times: When you send your emails can significantly affect open rates. A/B testing different send times can help you identify when your audience will most likely engage with your emails.
  8. From Name and Email Address: The sender's name and email address can impact the open rates. Testing different sender names and addresses can give you insights into what your audience trusts and prefers.

By A/B testing these elements, you can gain invaluable insights into your audience's preferences, improve your email marketing performance, and ultimately increase your return on investment.

Setting Up Your Email A/B Test

In A/B testing, your audience is the key. Always set up your tests keeping in mind the preferences and behaviors of your target audience.

A Step-by-step Guide to Setting Up A/B Test Email Campaign

Setting up a productive A/B test for a new feature in your email campaign involves strategic planning and meticulous implementation. Here's a straightforward step-by-step guide to ease setting up your A/B test email campaign.

  1. Goal Definition: First and foremost, identify what you hope to achieve with your A/B testing. It could be boosting your open rates, enhancing click-through rates, increasing conversions, or any goal specific to your email marketing strategy.
  2. Element Selection for Test: This could be anything ranging from the subject line, email body, call to action, design of the email, or any other component that you think could significantly affect the outcome of your email campaign.
  3. Creation of Variations: Develop two versions of your email - the first being version A (control) and the second being version B (variant). Make sure you alter only a single element between these two versions to maintain the validity of your test results.
  4. List Segmentation: Divide your email list into two equal and random groups. One group will receive version A of your email, and the other version B.
  5. Test Duration: Depending on your email frequency, decide a timeline for your test. Usually, a few weeks should serve as an adequate starting point.
  6. Campaign Launch: Use your preferred email marketing software to distribute the two versions of your email to the two groups in your email list.
  7. Result Analysis: Post the test period, employ your email marketing software to evaluate the performance of the two email versions. Consider open rates, click-through rates, and conversions to determine which version performed better.
  8. Implementation of Winning Version: Once the results are in, incorporate the winning version into your broader email marketing strategy. Remember, continuous A/B testing is the key to ongoing improvement.

Crucial Factors to Consider for Accurate Results: A Practical View

When initiating your A/B test, several vital factors need to be considered to secure the precision of your results.

  1. Sample Size: An example can be an e-commerce store with an email list of 10,000 subscribers. You would want to ensure a large enough sample size, say 5,000 for each email version, to achieve statistically significant results.
  2. Testing One Element at a Time: Let's say you are testing the subject line and the email body at the same time. If version B performs better, you wouldn't know if the improved performance is due to the changed subject line, the altered email body, or both.
  3. Test Duration: Suppose you are a fashion retailer launching a new collection and will test it over two months. Running the test too long could expose it to external factors like seasonal trends or competitors' sales, impacting the results.
  4. Choosing the Right Metric: If your goal is to increase open rates, measuring success based on click-through rates is irrelevant. Ensure the metric aligns with your goal.

Using this guide and considering these vital factors, you are well-prepared to set up an A/B test for your email campaign. It can help you gain actionable insights and significantly bolster your email marketing performance.

Hypothesis, Prioritization, and Learning

Prioritizing A/B tests is not just about what to test, but when to test. Timing can make or break your results.

The Art of Hypothesizing in A/B Tests

Formulating a well-defined hypothesis is at the heart of every successful A/B test. A hypothesis is a predictive statement about the relationship between the variable you are changing (your "independent variable") and the outcome you are trying to influence (your "dependent variable").

For instance, let's consider the subject line of an email marketing campaign. An example of a hypothesis might be two different subject lines: "Including the company name in the subject line will increase the open rate." In this case, the independent variable is the inclusion of the company name in the subject line, and the dependent variable is the company name and the open rate.

Creating a hypothesis like this will guide your A/B test, ensuring that you are actively trying to learn something about your customers' behavior. It also ensures that you can measure the impact of your changes, making your A/B test more effective.

Prioritizing Your A/B Tests: A Guide

With so many elements in an email marketing campaign that can be A/B tested, such as the subject line, email body, call to action or design, it's crucial to prioritize your tests to maximize your learning and efficiency.

The ICE Score, which stands for Impact, Confidence, and Ease, is a simple and widely-used framework for prioritizing A/B tests.

  1. Impact: How much do you think changing this variable will improve your metric of interest (e.g., open rate, click-through rate)?
  2. Confidence: How sure are you that this change will have an impact?
  3. Ease: How easy is it to implement this change?

By ranking your potential A/B tests using this framework, you can identify the tests that are likely to have the biggest impact with the least effort and the highest confidence.

Building on Learnings: The Continuous Improvement Approach

A/B testing is not a one-and-done strategy. Each test provides an opportunity for learning and improvement. Every test's results, whether successful or not, provide insights into your customers' behavior and preferences. These insights are valuable data points that can inform future tests and shape your email marketing strategy.

For example, if you've found that personalizing the subject line with the recipient's name significantly improves your open rates, you might try further personalization in your next test. Perhaps you'll test using personalized product recommendations in the email body or different types of personalization in the subject line.

Remember, A/B testing is a journey, not a destination. By continuously learning from your tests and using these learnings to inform your future tests, you're on the path to continuous improvement in your email marketing performance.

Advanced Topics in Email A/B Testing

The 'perfect time' to send an email can vary greatly depending on your audience. A/B testing can help find that sweet spot.

Exploring Email Variables: What to Test and How?

In the realm of email A/B testing, the options for what you can test are nearly limitless. Each element can be tweaked and tested, from the subject line to the email body to the call to action, to find the most effective version. However, it's essential to approach this with a strategy in mind.

Begin by identifying which elements of your emails could potentially affect your desired outcome, whether open rate, click-through rate, or conversions. Consider the emails from the reader's perspective. How might different subject lines, word orders, or styles affect their engagement with the email?

For instance, you might hypothesize that a shorter, more concise email body will lead to higher click-through rates. You can test this by creating two versions of the email: one with a long body and long form copy, and one with a short form copy.

Delivery Time: When is the Perfect Time?

When it comes to email marketing, timing can be just as important as the content of the email itself. Testing the optimal time to send your emails can be a game-changer for email marketing campaigns.

To test this, you can send the same email at different times of the day or different days of the week to segments of your email list. Then, track which delivery times result in the highest open or click-through rates. You might be surprised that your emails perform best at times you wouldn't have expected!

Testing Preheader Text for Optimum Performance

The preheader text is the short summary text that follows the subject line when an email is viewed in the inbox. This often-overlooked element can significantly impact whether a recipient decides to open your email or not.

A good preheader complements your subject line and provides more information about what's inside the email. It can help to pique the recipient's curiosity and encourage them to open the email. Test different versions of your preheader text to see which ones perform best.

What Else Can You Test?

Beyond the abovementioned variables, you can test many other elements in your email campaigns. You could test different types of personalization, such as using the recipient's name in the email body or subject line.

You could also test different designs or layouts for your emails. For example, you could compare the performance of a plain text email, versus multiple images text or an email with multiple images and text.

The possibilities for testing are only limited by your imagination and the specific needs of your email marketing strategy.

Tools to Use: Do You Need Specialised Tools?

There are many tools available that can simplify the process of setting up, running, and analyzing email A/B tests. Here are a few popular ones:

  1. Mailchimp: This popular email marketing software includes built-in A/B testing features.
  2. Optimizely: Optimizely offers robust A/B testing tools for emails, landing pages, and more.
  3. HubSpot: HubSpot's email marketing software includes A/B testing capabilities and a suite of other marketing tools.
  4. Campaign Monitor: This tool offers A/B testing capabilities and a range of other features for email marketing.
  5. ActiveCampaign: ActiveCampaign offers A/B email testing as part of its comprehensive marketing automation platform.

While these tools can streamline the A/B testing process, they're not strictly necessary. You can run A/B tests using your regular email marketing software with manual effort. However, as your email marketing campaigns grow in complexity and scale, using a specialized tool for A/B testing can save you time and provide more sophisticated analytics.

The Do's and Don'ts of Email A/B Testing

The effectiveness of A/B testing is not only determined by what you test but also how you interpret and implement the results.

Right and Wrong Ways to Conduct A/B Testing

Like any other marketing strategy, there's a right and wrong way to conduct email A/B testing. Here are some do's and don'ts email marketers to keep in mind:


  1. DO have a clear hypothesis: Before you begin your test, clearly understand what you're testing and why. Your hypothesis should guide the creation of your email variants and your analysis of the results.
  2. DO test one variable at a time: To get clear, actionable results from your A/B testing, testing only one variable at a time is essential. If you change multiple elements between your email variants, you won't be able to determine which change made the difference.
  3. DO use a significant sample size: To get reliable results, you need to use a sample size that's statistically significant. Too small a sample and your results might be due to chance.


  1. DON'T stop your tests too soon: Patience is a virtue in A/B testing. Let your test run long enough to gather significant data before drawing conclusions.
  2. DON'T ignore small wins: Even a small improvement in open rates or click-through rates can significantly impact over time, especially when sending emails to a large list.
  3. DON'T forget to learn from each test: Whether a test "succeeds" or "fails", there's always something to learn. Use the insights you gain to inform your future tests and continuously improve your email marketing.

Reducing Risk through Effective A/B Testing

Risk is inherent in any marketing strategy, and email marketing is no exception. However, you can reduce your risk significantly through effective A/B testing. Here's how:

Test Before You Roll Out: Before rolling out an email campaign, test your emails on a smaller segment of your list. This lets you iron out any potential issues before emailing your list.

Iterative Testing: Instead of making significant changes simultaneously, make more minor, iterative changes and test each one. This way, if a change doesn't have the desired effect, you haven't invested too much time or resources.

Start with High-Impact Areas: Prioritize your tests based on the potential impact. Start with areas of your email where a change is likely to significantly affect your KPIs, such as the subject line or call to action.

A/B testing for emails, when done right, can be a powerful tool to optimize your email marketing campaigns and improve your results over time. By following these do's and don'ts, you'll be well on your way to A/B testing success.

Real-life A/B Test Scenarios and Case Studies

Email A/B testing isn’t just about improving metrics; it’s about understanding your audience better.

In email marketing, A/B testing is a powerful tool to finetune campaigns and significantly enhance their performance. But reading about A/B testing in theory and seeing it in action are two different experiences. This section will take you on a journey through various real-life scenarios and case studies where A/B testing has helped businesses uncover surprising insights, make impactful changes, and reap measurable benefits. We will explore how A/B testing led to increased open rates, conversion rates, and profits, how it allowed for quicker results and more precise analysis, and how it worked in different scenarios. Get ready to gain practical insights into the art and science of A/B testing in the real world.

How A/B Testing Leads to Higher Open Rates, Conversion Rates, and Profits

A/B testing has been a game-changer for businesses aiming to optimize their email marketing strategy. By testing different variations of their emails, companies have witnessed substantial improvements in open rates, conversion rates, and, ultimately, profits. Let's dive into a couple of real-world examples to understand how this works:

Case Study 1 - Subject Line Testing:

Imagine an e-commerce company aiming to increase the open rates of its promotional emails. They recognize that the first thing a recipient sees is the subject line, which heavily influences whether they open the email. They decide to experiment with it.

In the test, they create two variations: Variation A has a straightforward, descriptive subject line, while Variation B uses a personalized, catchy phrase. They evenly split their subscriber list into two groups, sending Variation A to most subscribers in one group and Variation B to another.

When the results come in, they're remarkable. The emails with the catchy subject line (Variation B) experience an open rate that's 15% higher than those with the straightforward, descriptive subject line (Variation A). This uplift translates to a significant increase in potential customers reading their emails, a higher likelihood of conversions, and, thus, an opportunity for increased profits. It's a victory for the marketing team and a testament to the power of effective A/B testing.

Case Study 2 - Call-to-Action (CTA) Testing:

In another instance, let's consider a software-as-a-service (SaaS) company looking to increase the conversion rates for their product trial emails. They hypothesize that their call-to-action (CTA) might not be as compelling as it could be, prompting them to test this element.

In this experiment, they craft two different CTAs: Variation A remains their standard descriptive CTA, while Variation B incorporates language that incites a sense of urgency. Like the previous case study, they split their list into two equal segments and sent each a different version.

The results from this test provide another enlightening insight. The emails featuring the urgent CTA (Variation B) achieve a 10% higher conversion rate than those with the standard, descriptive CTA (Variation A). This finding gives the company a clear direction for future email campaigns: a sense of urgency can drive conversions.

Achieving Faster Results and More Precise Analysis

One of the most attractive aspects of A/B testing is its capacity to deliver faster results and facilitate more precise analysis. Businesses can identify the changes that drive desired outcomes, streamline their email marketing strategies, and achieve quicker wins by making data-driven decisions.

Case Study 3 - Image Testing:

Consider a company that sells beauty products online. They have a hunch that the images they use in their emails might affect their click-through rates. To test this hypothesis, they set up an A/B test comparing an email with a single product image against another, showcasing multiple images demonstrating the product in use.

The results of this test are striking. The emails with multiple images witness a 30% higher click-through rate than those with a single product image. This discovery enables the company to swiftly refine its email design strategy, leading to higher engagement with its emails, more website traffic, and an increased potential for conversions.

Examples of A/B Testing under Different Scenarios

Different scenarios require different types of A/B tests. The nature of your business, the nuances of your email list, and your objectives can shape the kind of A/B testing that would be most effective.

Scenario 1 - New Product Launch:

Suppose a tech company is preparing to launch a new product and wants to determine the most compelling way to introduce it to its email list. They could set up an A/B test comparing two different introduction emails: Variation A highlights one variation the product's features, while Variation B focuses on its benefits.

Scenario 2 - Holiday Promotion:

In another situation, imagine a retail company planning a holiday promotion. They're unsure which incentive would encourage more purchases—a discount code or a bonus gift. An A/B test could help them solve this dilemma.

Each of these real-life scenarios and case studies underscores the power and flexibility of A/B testing in driving the success of email marketing campaigns. They're a testament to the potential of data-driven decision-making and optimization in a world that increasingly values personalized, relevant communication.


A/B testing should be embraced, not feared. It’s a key to unlocking deeper understanding and delivering more value to your audience.

After deep diving into the world of email A/B testing, you may feel a mixture of excitement and overwhelm. The concepts, processes, and potentials we've explored can seem complex, but remember; every expert was once a beginner. The key is to start small, learn, adjust, and expand your testing efforts gradually.

In this conclusion, we'll summarize the most important aspects to remember, from a quick recap of why A/B testing should not be feared to a quick reference guide to A/B testing terminology. We'll also list the most common variations you can A/B test in your email campaigns.

List of Things You Can A/B Test and the Most Common Variations

First, let's revisit the universe of elements within your emails that you can A/B test. This is by no means exhaustive, but it will certainly give you a great starting point.

  1. Subject lines: Test the tone (casual versus formal), length, use of emojis, personalization, and so on.
  2. Email body: Test different copies, font styles, sizes, lengths, tones, etc.
  3. Call to actions: Test different colors, placement, wording, size, and so on.
  4. Images: Test no image versus image, one image versus multiple images, etc.
  5. Personalization: Test name personalization, personalized recommendations, personalized subject lines, etc.
  6. Preview text: Test different lengths, tones, use of emojis, personalization, and so on.
  7. Delivery times: Test different times of the day, different days of the week, and so on.

Why A/B Testing Shouldn't Be Feared: A Recap

A/B testing is a powerful tool, but it's also one that many marketers approach with a degree of trepidation. It's important to understand that A/B testing isn't something to fear; rather, it's something to embrace. Yes, it involves some additional work, but the insights it can provide are invaluable.

  1. A/B testing gives you data-driven insights: Instead of relying on gut feelings or assumptions about your audience, A/B testing gives you solid data to base your decisions on.
  2. It can significantly improve your email performance: By continuously testing and tweaking your emails, you can significantly improve your open rates, click-through rates, and conversions.
  3. A/B testing allows you to understand your audience better: The data from your A/B tests can give you deeper insights into your audience's preferences and behaviors, allowing you to serve them better.

A/B Testing Terminology: Quick Reference Guide

Finally, as we wrap up, here's a quick reference guide to some of the most common terms we've used throughout this guide:

  1. A/B Testing: Also known as split testing, A/B testing involves comparing two versions of an email to see which performs better.
  2. Variables: The elements you change in your A/B test (e.g., subject line, email body, call to action).
  3. Control: The original version of your email.
  4. Variant: The version of your email includes the changes you're testing.
  5. Sample Size: The number of recipients you send your A/B test to.
  6. Statistical Significance: A statistical measure that quantifies the certainty of the results of your A/B test.
  7. Open Rate: The percentage of recipients who open your email.
  8. Click-through Rate (CTR): The percentage of recipients who click on a link within your email.

The world of A/B testing is fascinating and offers endless opportunities to learn and grow. Take your first step worth testing today, and let the journey unfold at its pace.

Outbound sales tech stack, all on Alore.  Run your complete outbound sales workflow on Alore, from Warming up email to running drip campaigns, fixing meetings, and managing inboxes.

What is Alore?

Email Warmer

Generate real engagement to Warm Up Your Email Address without any human intervention

Drip Campaigner

Send emails that generate new business opprotunities for you

Collaborative Inbox

Improve team performance & customer experience - manage multiple email addresses from one place